Kelly O'Connor

If you’ve ever delved into the world of personal finance and investing, chances are you’ve come across the name Dave Ramsey. Known for his financial advice and guidance, Ramsey has built quite a reputation. But like all financial pundits, his advice deserves a closer examination, especially when it comes to his claims about mutual fund returns.

Ramsey has long advocated for a seemingly attractive proposition: a 12% return on mutual fund investments. However, this assertion begs for examination, and an article of his only serves to emphasize the need for careful examination of such claims. Let’s dissect the claims and see what’s really beneath the surface.

In his article, Ramsey takes a two-decade span, from 1990 to 2009, and averages out the returns of the S&P 500 index to arrive at a seemingly respectable 10% average rate of return. At first glance, this might seem reasonable, but let’s dig deeper into the three critical mistakes that Ramsey makes and why this claim doesn’t hold up to scrutiny.

Mistake 1: Averages Don’t Reflect Reality

First and foremost, the average rate of return is not reflective of actual market fluctuations. Investing is a roller coaster ride, with ups and downs that can significantly impact your overall returns. If we look at the actual performance over these two decades, it’s apparent that the reality is different from the average presented. Averaging out returns might smooth out the numbers, but it doesn’t accurately capture the volatility that investors experience.

Mistake 2: The Impact of Fees

Another key factor that Ramsey fails to adequately address is the impact of fees. Many mutual funds come with fees that can eat into your returns. These fees include annual expenses, transaction fees, and more. Even if Ramsey’s claims of a 12% return were accurate, once you factor in these fees, your actual returns might fall far short of his promised 12%.

Mistake 3: Ignoring Tax Implications

Finally, the impact of taxes on investment returns is a crucial consideration. Different types of investments have varying tax implications. For instance, gains from stocks and bonds are treated differently for tax purposes. Failing to account for these tax consequences can lead to a significant discrepancy between projected returns and actual take-home gains.

Let’s put this into perspective with a practical example. If you were to start with $100,000 and experience the actual market fluctuations of the S&P 500 over these two decades, after considering fees and taxes, your ending balance might be drastically different from what Ramsey’s claim suggests. In fact, your actual rate of return might be much lower than the projected 10% or 12%.

The Bottom Line

While Dave Ramsey’s advice has helped many individuals navigate their financial journeys, it’s essential to critically examine claims like a guaranteed 12% return on mutual fund investments. Investing is complex, and real-world factors like market volatility, fees, and taxes can significantly impact your actual returns.

Instead of relying solely on bold claims, it’s wise to approach investment decisions with a clear understanding of these critical factors. Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just beginning your financial journey, seeking advice from financial professionals and thoroughly researching your investment options will serve you far better than simply accepting blanket statements about returns.

Remember, a successful investment strategy requires a comprehensive understanding of the market, careful consideration of fees and taxes, and a willingness to adapt to changing economic conditions. By avoiding the allure of too-good-to-be-true promises and focusing on sound financial principles, you can make informed decisions that align with your long-term financial goals.

Related Blogs

Unveiling the Truth: Average vs. Actual Investment Returns

We all want to make reasonable financial decisions for the future. However,

Read More

Cracking the Code: Pre-Tax vs. Post-Tax Investments

When it comes to investing for your future, the choices can sometimes

Read More

Decoding Insurance Commissions vs. Asset Management Fees: Unveiling the Truth

Welcome, readers! Today, we’re delving into a topic that often sparks heated

Read More

Kelly O’Connor is a master coach and trainer with a decades-long career in sales, marketing, and insurance. An industry leader, alongside top producers developing programs, he quickly became Colorado’s #1 speaker within the charter school system, traveling the state to speak in front of thousands of people and financial planners. A true visionary and figurehead for the community, he’s invested hundreds of thousands of dollars in marketing, coaching, and training masterminds and mentors.

hear what our clients have said

Hollie Clere,  Social Media Strategist

After having had a bad experience with a financial person in the past, I asked Kelly some hard questions before even introducing him to my husband. Most of it had to do with trust, focus and decisions we had gotten hurt with in the past. Kelly not only paid attention to every detail to the aspects to my questions but showed me where we had made some great choices and talked about the importance of each decision. He nis relationship focused. When my husband met him, Jer’s demeanor switched from debate to encouragement. Kelly’s presence alone made my husband comfortable and they visited about a lot of aspects of things.

Greg Peterson,  Founding Partner

Kelly was excellent to work with. His different approach at looking at money was an eye opener to us. We will continue to work with Kelly in the future and highly recommend having Kelly involved when it comes to investing.

Edward Hilton,  Chief Technology Officer

Kelly has exceeded all of my expectations. He provided education, experience, excellence and integrity! This is so important when working with a client's personal finances. As a school educator I appreciate his focus on education so that I could make the most informed financial decisions. I have a much clearer understanding of banking, finance, and investment now, and this will help my family currently and in the years to come. Thank you Kelly and kudos to the Mountain Financial team!